National Trust Statement of Significance Framework Project
Caroe Architecture Ltd (CAL) has had the privilege of developing a framework for Statements of Significance with the National Trust. We have created four exemplar documents, each focusing on one asset within the Blickling Estate: the Hall, Lothian Barns, Parkland and Garden and the Collection. These will be distributed nationally to set the standard for documents of this type.
The process for creating each statement was collaborative. We applied heritage values set out by the Trust – evidential value, historical value, people value and aesthetic value – which were incorporated into an overall assessment for each asset. This was then compared with similar assets – nationally and internationally – and quantified using the Trust’s rating scale:
1. Exceptional
2. Considerable
3. Moderate
4. Some
5. Unknown
6. Detrimental
Drafts were developed by CAL in collaboration with industry leaders. These were then discussed with the Trust, who distributed them throughout the organisation – capturing a wide range of expertise and ensuring that each assessment incorporated a range of viewpoints. Feedback was given in three review meetings, where the model was refined further. The finished documents represent the culmination of this, presenting an understanding of each asset and their significance with accuracy and concision.
The project benefitted from the detailed research of the Conservation Management Plan, authored by CAL in 2021. This, and other key sources, were referenced throughout. However, some elements had not been assessed in detail, such as the Lothian Barns, and, for these, original research was required – using fabric analysis supported by map evidence.
Plans were developed to supplement this understanding: phasing plans, significance plans, key views plans and, in the case of the Gardens and Parkland statement, a character area plan. These can be viewed alongside as-proposed drawings to ensure change is managed with sensitivity to historic fabric.
Presentation was of the utmost importance. Both Adobe Indesign and Microsoft Word were employed to create clear and eye-catching documents, easily re-purposed as templates. Each statement is fully illustrated, including with historic images, which aid understanding and better communicate a sense of place. It is hoped that our work can assist with the management and preservation of the treasured heritage assets in the care of the Trust.